"Toogood Pond is known as one of Markhams beautiful landmarks, but it looks more like a swamp lately, and most residents have no idea what is happening." That was how the Markham Review opened its September 23, 2026 report on the pond. The low water isn't left over from a dry summer. The paper reports that it comes from a multi-year City of Markham plan for the park.
Read the coverage closely and the work turns out to be two projects. One is a repair of the dam. The other covers the boardwalks and the fishing pier. They started at different times, they answer to different constraints, and only one of them has a public finish date right now. Once you see the two clocks, the closed fencing along the loop makes sense, and so does the timing of when each part of the park comes back.
Clock One: The Dam, Which Is Why the Water Is Low
Phase 2 of the dam rehabilitation started in late July. According to the Markham Economist & Sun, the work involves dewatering areas around the dam foundation to expose the concrete footings, repairing the concrete, and installing a cofferdam to manage water downstream. Exposing those footings is what pulled the pond down to the level you see from the shore.
The City awarded the construction contract, tender 048-T-26, on June 30, 2026. The tender listed a duration of two months. Phase 2 was supposed to finish in October. The paper reports that weather affected the schedule and that the City is reviewing a revised completion date. The Markham Review put it more plainly: "a new deadline is currently being reviewed."
The dam work also has to fit around a constraint that doesn't apply to the boardwalk crews. The project went through an environmental review and received a provincial permit that included an approved fisheries plan. The Markham Review identifies it as a Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry permit that sets out how fish and aquatic habitat must be protected during construction. An environmental consultant is monitoring aquatic conditions and carrying out fish rescues. Certain in-water activities are limited to a July-to-September work window.
As of today, October 3, that window has closed. The City hasn't said publicly which of the remaining dam tasks count as in-water work, and none of the coverage gives a date for the pond to refill. Anyone hoping to see a full pond by a particular weekend has no published date to plan around.
Clock Two: The Boardwalk and Pier, Which Do Have a Date
The closures you'll run into on a walk belong to the second project. The north boardwalk and the fishing pier are both closed. Crews are fixing a settlement problem under the fishing pier before restoring its walkway. The north boardwalk is getting structural rehabilitation and replacement of deteriorated components.
This work traces back to inspections in 2024 of three boardwalk structures and a pedestrian bridge, which found that rehabilitation was needed. It began in early August and is expected to be finished by November, weather and site conditions permitting. The Markham Review also reports that the closed walking areas and both structures are set to reopen in November 2026.
When the crews finish, the boardwalks, the bridge and the fishing pier will have new wood surfaces, with the structures underneath rehabilitated or replaced. Closed pathways will reopen and construction areas will be restored.
So the likely order this fall is that the paths come back first and the water level follows on its own schedule. The north boardwalk could be open in November while the pond beside it is still low.
The Whole Project, Laid End to End
Seen together, the phases explain why the fencing has been up longer than one season:
- Phase 1, finished in 2024. Safety signs and fencing around the park.
- Phase 2, started late July 2026. Dam rehabilitation, including dewatering, repairs to the concrete footings and a downstream cofferdam. The original October finish is under review.
- Boardwalk and pier work, started early August 2026. Expected to reopen in November 2026.
- Phase 3, starting early 2027. Clearing vegetation, removing trees identified for removal, and restoring the dam embankments. The Markham Economist & Sun expects it to wrap up around mid-2027.
"The dam will ultimately be rehabilitated to meet current safety and regulatory requirements."
That line from the Markham Economist & Sun sums up where the project ends. Phase 3 has its own practical meaning for the park. Tree removal on the embankments next year means the edges of the pond will look different again in spring 2027, after the boardwalks have reopened.
One gap is worth knowing about. None of the coverage includes a posted detour map or marks exactly where each closed section starts and ends. The north boardwalk and the fishing pier are the only closures named. Expect to find out the rest on the ground, from the fencing.
Where the October Walk Goes Instead
With the north boardwalk closed until at least November, October is the month the pond loop is at its shortest. It's also the month Main Street Unionville has its fullest calendar of the fall. The street reopened with a celebration on May 30 after the City's restoration project, which added new pavers, lighting and street furniture. This is the rebuilt street's first fall season of events. The Unionville BIA and the Varley Art Gallery of Markham list the following as scheduled:
- Saturday, October 11, 10 to 11 a.m.: A free Historic Unionville Walking Tour leaves from the Millennium Bandstand, led by the author of Historic Unionville – a Village in the City. Registration is required.
- Friday, October 16, 7 p.m.: Boots for Art at the Varley, a line-dancing night with Cheatin' Hearts leading. Tickets include two drinks, and proceeds support the gallery's 30th anniversary in 2027.
- Saturday, October 17, 2 p.m.: Study Hall Sessions at the Varley, free and drop-in.
- Sunday, October 18, 10:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.: Fibre Art: Harvest Pumpkin in Wool, a wet-felting workshop for ages 16 and up. Registration is required.
- Saturday, October 24, 10:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.: The Varley's free Art Bus, with guided visits to the Aga Khan Museum, the Varley's exhibition I Think This Means I Can Fly, and the Doris McCarthy Gallery. Registration is required.
- Sunday, October 25, 1 to 4 p.m.: Halloween on Main, with $5 face painting and Dan the Music Man performing from 2 p.m. Between 1 and 3 p.m. that day, the Varley runs a Haunted Halloween workshop for children ages 5 to 8.
- Wednesday, November 11, 10:50 a.m.: Remembrance Day on Main, with short speeches and a wreath laying at the cenotaph at Crosby Community Arena.
The calendar's own timing lines up with the pond. Remembrance Day falls in the same month the north boardwalk and fishing pier are expected to reopen, so mid-November may be the first week since early August that the full pond loop and Main Street are both open together. That depends on the weather, the same condition the City attached to every date it has published.
The street also has a couple of newer places to stop. Hello Markham reported in June that Nisa's Cakes & Café and Trio Pastry Café were both open on Main Street Unionville. The BIA directory lists Nisa's at 209 Main Street Unionville, Unit 4.
What to Watch For Between Now and Spring
Three things are still unannounced: a revised finish date for Phase 2, a date for the pond to refill, and a confirmed reopening day for the north boardwalk and fishing pier. The first two depend on the dam, and the third depends on the boardwalk crews. When the City announces any of them, the other two won't automatically follow, because the projects run on separate schedules. Then, in early 2027, Phase 3 brings crews back to the embankments for vegetation and tree work, with completion expected around the middle of the year.
If you own near Toogood Pond and are thinking about selling in the next year, these dates matter for how your home is shown. Listing photos and video taken this fall would show a low pond and closed boardwalks. Spring 2027 will bring embankment work. Digalakis Real Estate can help you choose a photo and video window that shows the park well once the boardwalks reopen, and plan around the Phase 3 work after it. Book a complimentary consultation and we'll plan the timing with you.